Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Useful Parts for Wagon Builders

by John Kendall

Most of us have built, at one time or another, plastic wagon kits.  Almost all of us railway modellers will have RTR wagons.  These generally have one thing in common, poor representations of the brake gear, particularly clasp brake gear.  More recently, and Hornby leaps to mind, wagon underframes are beginning to improve, with the latest GWR horsebox having exquisitely detailed brake gear.

Now, unfitted wagons have quite simple brake gear and kits and RTR examples are usually good enough.  Sme wagons had a rod connecting the left and right actuators but not always.  Some wagons only had brakes on one side - these designs would date from the late 19th century - the Board of Trade made it mandatory to be able to apply brakes from either side of the wagon, early in the 20th century, for safety's sake.

It's when we start getting into the realm of fitted (with vacuum brakes) wagons where things get dicey.  Some observations of kits:

1)  Brake parts being plastic and necessarily fine are fragile.
2)  Details provided in the kit are usually sketchy - you might get lump of plastic that's supposed to be a vacuum cylinder.
3)  There are usually no instructions provided as to how to rig the wagon's brakes.

So, what is the modeller who is serious about constructing good looking wagons to do?  Two things:

1)  Learn how the pros do it and find out what the prototype looked like.
2)  Obtain the necessary parts to supplement or replace those provided in kits.

So, first, I would recommend  that the modeller obtain books/DVDs on the subject.  Such as:

a)  The 4mm Wagon - 3 Volumes by Geoff Kent

http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/1874103038.php
http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/1874103240.php
http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/1874103976.php

b)  A Guide to 4mm Coal Wagon Building by John Hayes

http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/1874103488.php

c)  Official Drawings of LMS Wagons - 2 Volumes by Bob Essery

http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/1874103305.php
http://britishrailwaybooks.co.uk/books/ISBN/187410333x.html

All the above are published by Wild Swan, so check them all out.

d)  Right Track 13 and 14, Wagons, hosted by Iain Rice

http://www.model-railway-dvd.co.uk/right_track13.php
http://www.model-railway-dvd.co.uk/right_track14.php

Just a word of caution, Activity Media won't ship to North America for insurance reasons so you'll have to work around that somehow.

Next, where to get parts?  Easy, there are a couple of sources I can think of but I have the following in stock from Mainly Trains http://www.mainlytrains.co.uk/acatalog/by-mainlytrainsmiscsuppliers.html:



These are designed and etched by Iain Rice who is an authority on wagons.

Here's an example of a wagon I made some years ago.







This is made from a Chivers etched brass kit.  The kit comes with basically no underframe detail at all so I had to build it all.  This is an example of a through piped brake van - one not fitted with vacuum brake itself but where the guard can control the train brakes, and the van brakes manually.  The vacuum pipe is visible as are the yokes for the clasp brakes.  Safety loops are made from wire.

So, there is no reason to slavishly stick to what the kit and manufacturers provide.  With a bit of knowledge and a box full of bits you can make your wagons a cut above the rest.

Monday, July 2, 2012

BR Conflat L Build

by John Kendall

I started to build my Conflat L today.  It's another Bill Bedford kit and details can be found here:  http://www.mousa.biz/fourmm/wagons/br_wagons4.html

Mine is intended to be used as a runner for my Class 03 diesel shunter.  These locomotives needed something to trip track circutry that indicated there was a train on the line.  The 03 has a short wheelbase and it was found, in some regions, that it could "disappear".  Permanently attaching a wagon was a way around the problem.  Conflat A wagons were also used, but models of these are common and I wanted something different.

Pictures of these can be found here:  http://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/conflatl/h1bf074b0#h1bf074b0

The first step in the model build is the sides.  The picture shows one I did earlier and the parts required to build up the side.



I'm glad I did these one at a time because there is a learning curve and I messed things first time around.  The great thing about brass is that mistakes can usually be corrected by desoldering and trying again - so it was here.

My first note is that on the piece 3rd from the bottom, there is a half etch that doesn't apparently do anything.  The half etch make that location extremely weak and, yes, I broke it on my first attempt.  You will see that I have reinforced it with some solder.

The solebar is made up of the first and pieces from the bottom.  The first piece is actually pictured with the front facing down.  The rectangular sections are half etched and will fold toward the viewer later.

Tin the second part and position on the first part.  Flux and apply the iron starting from the center and working out holding the piece down with a small screwdriver as you go.  Repeat for the other end.

Use a fiberglass pencil to clean up the work as you go.  This works well to remove excess solder.

On the third part, make a bend with the half etch to the inside (this is a convention in brass kits and will always be so unless otherwise specified).  To get a straight bend I used a largish file to hold one half of the part down while using, initially a chisel Xacto blad and later a steel rule to complete the bend.  Tweak it with some square head pliers.  There are tools to do this so shop around.

There's a short piece on the left that folds up about 30 degrees - solder this in place.

Tin the back of the 4th piece and place on the box you just made.  The location should be evident.  Sweat it in place as was done before.

Piece 3 has tabs which locate at the bottom of the solebar.  These should be soldered in place at this time.

Fold the top pieces of the solebar inwards and reinforce with solder.

There are 3 reinforcing pieces with holes in them (not shown in the picture).  These are soldered at the ends and one in the middle.  The instructions are clear on this.

3 July 2012

I completed the other side yesterday - much easier when you know what you're doing.  Today, I tackled the spring snubbers as follows:

1) Take down the etch tag by gripping the (oh so tiny!) piece in flat headed pliers and filing off with fine file.
2) Make the end bends first. Reinforce with solder.  Then using a piece of waste fret (about the right thickness I found) as a form, push down on both legs trying to exert even pressure. With the bent piece balanced on the edge of the fret, finish the bend with needly nose pliers. I found, with a bit of practice that I could make a reasonably square looking "hat".
3) Take off a really tiny (not more than 0.010" thick) piece of solder. Lay the hat on the bench and flux it. Hold down with a small screwdriver, pick up the solder with your iron and apply to the hat. With a bit of luck, the bends will now be reinforced.
4) Lay the solebar flat on the workbench. Put the hat in the center of the W iron (if it won't go, open the base of the W iron slightly until it does). Put a tiny amount of solder where the snubber will go (as in 3)). Position the snubber, flux, hold with screwdriver (about now I'm hoping to evolve a third hand) and apply the iron.


The final step on the sides was brake ratchets.  These consist of a a strip of brass, folded at stratgeic places.  I found it useful to make about half of the folds and then reinforce these with solder, and then to complete the shape.  These are finally soldered in place.  As usual, they are a fiddle but I seem to be getting better at this.


That is one cruel closeup.

The next phase is to assemble the deck.


Top view.



Bottom View.
This is all pretty straightforward.  The beams in the center fold up and are soldered in place as shown.  Make sure they are straight.  If I was to do again I would start the solder at the middle and finish at the ends.
There are spring retainers which fold up and get reinforced with solder.
There is no positive locator for the top deck - I did this by eye.  I added eight dabs of solder to the underside of the deck, positioned it carefully again (I bodged it the first time) and sweated it in place.  I then turned it over and did the same from the bottom trying to ensure that deck is lying flat on the frame.

The next step is to fix the sides to the deck.  I found the fit to be tight and did some fettling with a file to get to the point where the sides would sit down DEAD flat against the deck.  When happy, solder it all up.





There are 8 spring wire retainers.  Make sure these are in contact with the sides.  If they are not the spring wire will come adrift.

It's certainly not pretty at this stage but it is starting to look like the wagon and it does seem square.

6 July 2012

I got the brake gear done today.  This wagon is Automatic Vacuum Brake (AVB) fitted:



There are brakes on all four wheels that can be actuated either manually or automatically using vacuum power.

The brake assemblies make up in the same way as on the ballast wagon:
The brakes are a double thickness fold up, with brake shoes and crank sandwiched in between.  This, as usual, is a tad fiddly.  First, I tinned the brake shoes.  Then, I put the shoes in between the two halves being careful to position it correctly.  Use a convex file to get the curved profile of the brakes.  Application of the iron causes the solder to flow and for the parts to be bonded.  I positioned the brake assembly, first tinning the underside.  I made sure of the position by threading the supplied wire through all the holes.  Use a broach to open holes that are too small.

For manual actuation, there is a lever on both sides.  For mechanical reasons, one of these has a clutch.  I couldn't work out if there a particular side for the clutch.

For automatic actuation the is a vacuum cylinder which pushes on a rod that actuates the brakes.

The kit supplies two of each lever.  Take one plain and one clutched and bend as indicated in the instructions.  Installed with the handle through the ratchet and the hole over the brake rod.  Solder in place.

The kit includes a casting to represent the vacuum cylinder.  Make sure it is square at the top (mine wasn't).  You will need to drill a hole for the piston rod and use some brass wire.  I chose 0.020".

Strangely, there is no actuator arm, I sourced one from my bits box (a useful thing to have - see post 4 July).  Edit, 7 July - there is one, I missed it.

I turned my attention next to the deck and the container brackets.  These fold up at a 90 degree angle and have a tab which fits in a slot.  Getting these on was no easy task.  I finally found the better way was to:

a) cut a small piece of solder off the roll
b) flux the loctaion on the deck where you want to put the bracket
c) grab the bracket with needle nose pliers and flux it
d) position the bracket on the deck
e) pick up the solder on the iron tip and apply to the bracket.  Check that the bracket is square - it probably won't be.
f) reflux
g) hold the top of the bracket with something flat (I used a small file) and put the iron inside the fold of the bracket while pushing gently with your flat thing.  With good fortune the bracket should seat properly.  Don't push too hard or the bracket will break (I did this twice, luckily there are two spare brakets).
h) clean the excess solder with a combination of fiberglass pen, file and, where you have made a real mess, desolder braid.






7 July 2012

Today I turned my attention to getting the axleboxes and buffers installed.  Axleboxes are a breeze, they fit first time and all they needed was some superglue to secure them.

I had intended to try to spring the buffers, having failed in this for the ballast wagon.  However, when trial fitting on eof the buffer housings in the wagon, the spigot broke off.  That put the kibosh on springing.  I don't seem to have much luck with sprung buffers.  I'm also thinking that the 3D print material might be a little too fragile or perhaps the right word is brittle.  Plastic or metal would be a better choice I think.

Almost finished now:





Those wheels are Bachmann.  It runs freely and smoothly.

Fitting of the Kadee coupling is similar in concept to that of the ballast wagon:



After fitting the Kadee mounting pad, but not the coupling, it was off to the paint shop.  A primer coat of red oxide followed by black.  The protruding sides were painted BR bauxite.

The lettering on this wagon is very specialized, so I made my own.  It doesn't exactly match the picture that I used,  http://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/conflatl/h1bf074b0#h1bf074b0, but it's not bad.





These pictures show the wagon in its' intended role - as a runner for my 03 shunter.  Note the lamps over the buffer beam, one red and one white, denoting staion pilot.

I had to spend some time faffing about getting the springs working freely and getting the wagon to sit square.

This cruel close up shows that I have some work to do on the 03 cab door windows.  I reworked them to be open so that the sound comes out better.

20 July 2012

Last weekend I had another go at fixing the windows: